Friday, July 4, 2025
Digital Rights Monitor
  • DRM Exclusive
    • News
    • Court Updates
    • Features
    • Comment
    • Campaigns
      • #PrivacyHumSabKe
    • Vodcasts
  • In Media
    • News
    • OP-EDs
  • Editorial
  • Gender & Tech
    • SheConnects
  • Trends Monitor
  • Infographics
  • Resources
    • Laws and Policies
    • Research
    • International Frameworks
  • DRM Advocacy
    • Exclusives
    • Featured
    • Publications
    • Statements
No Result
View All Result
Digital Rights Monitor
  • DRM Exclusive
    • News
    • Court Updates
    • Features
    • Comment
    • Campaigns
      • #PrivacyHumSabKe
    • Vodcasts
  • In Media
    • News
    • OP-EDs
  • Editorial
  • Gender & Tech
    • SheConnects
  • Trends Monitor
  • Infographics
  • Resources
    • Laws and Policies
    • Research
    • International Frameworks
  • DRM Advocacy
    • Exclusives
    • Featured
    • Publications
    • Statements
No Result
View All Result
Digital Rights Monitor
No Result
View All Result

in In Media, News

Facebook transcribed users’ audio and passed it on — report

DRMby DRM
August 14, 2019

News Source: DW

Hundreds of contractors have been hired by Facebook to listen and transcribe audio recorded from users, according to a Bloomberg report. Some of the contractors reportedly felt their work was “unethical.”

Facebook has tested their transcription tool by having outside contractors listen to audio recordings of their users, US media reported on Tuesday. 

The practice, which was reported by Bloomberg, involved the users of Facebook Messenger. The report said the social media giant sent audio of anonymous conversations to at least one California-based company where human employees would listen and transcribe it.

Facebook has since said it stopped transcribing the audio recordings. “Much like Apple and Google, we paused human review of audio more than a week ago,” the company said to Bloomberg on Tuesday.

‘Conspiracy theory’

Facebook has long dismissed the rumors that it was listening to users’ private conversations in order to target them with ads.

In a testimony before Congress last year, the company CEO Mark Zuckerberg called it a “conspiracy theory.”

“You’re talking about this conspiracy theory that gets passed around that we listen to what’s going on on your microphone and use that for ads,” he told US lawmakers.

“We don’t do that.”

Only with permission

On Tuesday, Facebook confirmed to Bloomberg the report but said it only affected the users who opted to have their voice chats transcribed.

According to the article, Facebook has never informed users that third parties may review their audio. The company’s privacy policy says its “systems automatically process content and communications you and others provide” — but it does not mention audio or human teams transcribing it.

When it comes to sharing user’s data with third parties, the company refers to “vendors and service providers who support our business,” but does not provide details.

Reviewers ‘rattled’

The contractors were not told how the audio was recorded or obtained. Facebook also did not tell them why the audio needed to be transcribed, Bloomberg reported.

Some of the employees felt their work was unethical and were rattled by the content, which occasionally contained vulgarity.

The latest report comes after Amazon, Apple, and Google all came under criticism for collecting snippets from users’ conversations and passing them on to human reviewers. All three digital giants offer their own versions of voice assistants capable of responding to human speech.

Apple and Google have since said they would no longer use human reviewers to improve speech recognition and Amazon said it would let users opt out of the practice.

dj/stb (AFP, Reuters)

Tags: BloombergconversationsdataprivacyFacebooksurveillance
Previous Post

Kashmir blackout triggers online misinformation war

Next Post

Watching over: Why mothers must be educated on digital safety

Share on FacebookShare on Twitter
Microsoft slashes 6,000 jobs, trimming 3% of its global workforce in major shake-up.

Microsoft to Slash 9,000 Jobs Amid AI Shift

July 3, 2025
As AI Enters Newsrooms, MMfD Launches ‘Sahafat.AI’ to Put Journalists in Control

As AI Enters Newsrooms, MMfD Launches ‘Sahafat.AI’ to Put Journalists in Control

June 30, 2025
IRAN: Ban on WhatsApp, Google Play lifted

National CERT Issues Warning Over WhatsApp Phishing Surge

June 18, 2025
No Content Available

Next Post
Illustration by Aniqa Haider

Watching over: Why mothers must be educated on digital safety

About Digital Rights Monitor

This website reports on digital rights and internet governance issues in Pakistan and collates related resources and publications. The site is a part of Media Matters for Democracy’s Report Digital Rights initiative that aims to improve reporting on digital rights issues through engagement with media outlets and journalists.

About Media Matters for Democracy

Media Matters for Democracy is a Pakistan based not-for-profit geared towards independent journalism and media and digital rights advocacy. Founded by a group of journalists, MMfD works for innovation in media and journalism through the use of technology, research, and advocacy on media and internet related issues. MMfD works to ensure that expression and information rights and freedoms are protected in Pakistan.

Follow Us on Twitter

Welcome Back!

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • DRM Exclusive
    • News
    • Court Updates
    • Features
    • Comment
    • Campaigns
      • #PrivacyHumSabKe
    • Vodcasts
  • In Media
    • News
    • OP-EDs
  • Editorial
  • Gender & Tech
    • SheConnects
  • Trends Monitor
  • Infographics
  • Resources
    • Laws and Policies
    • Research
    • International Frameworks
  • DRM Advocacy
    • Exclusives
    • Featured
    • Publications
    • Statements